| Track | Artist | Song | Episode | Context |
| 1 | Dandy Warhols | Bohemian Like You | 5x11 - Triangle | This song is playing when Olaf arrives at the Bronze. |
| 2 | Summercamp | Play It By Ear | 5x14 - Crush | This song plays in the opening scene in the Bronze as Buffy looks on while the gang dances. |
| 3 | Blur | There's No Other Way | 5x11 - Triangle | This song plays as Spike and Xander talk in the Bronze. |
| 4 | THC | Dip | 4x06 - Wild At Heart | THC is the real band playing the music of Shy; this is the song Shy plays on stage in the first scene at the Bronze. |
| 5 | Yo La Tengo | Tears Are In Your Eyes | 5x06 - Family | This song plays as Sandy tries to pick up Riley at Willy's Place. |
| 6 | Sprung Monkey | Things Are Changing | 1x01 - Welcome To The Hellmouth | The band plays this on stage at The Bronze before Buffy leaves to save Willow. |
| 7 | Four Star Mary | Fate | 2x04 - Inca Mummy Girl | The music of Oz's band, Dingoes Ate My Baby, is provided by the band Four Star Mary. On stage at the Bronze at the Cultural Exchange Dance, Dingoes/FSM play "Shadows" first and then, as Xander asks Ampata to Dance, "Fate." |
| 8 | Caviar | I Thought I Was Found | 4x18 - Where The Wild Things Are | |
| 9 | Average White Band | Got The Love | 2x16 - Bewitched, Bothered, and Bewildered | This is the song playing on the soundtrack as Xander walks through the school hallway in slow motion, with girls staring and guys glaring. |
| 10 | Nickleback | Breathe | 5x04 - Out Of My Mind | This song plays as Riley plays basketball. |
| 11 | Willoughby | Lois On The Brink | 2x07 - Lie To Me | This song plays in the background as Willow and Xander play pool with Ford at the Bronze. |
| 12 | Bif Naked | Moment Of Weakness | 4x03 - The Harsh Light Of Day | Bif Naked appears at the frat party; this is the first song we hear her perform. |
| 13 | Vertical Horizon | Finding Me | 5x01 - Buffy vs. Dracula | This song plays during the beach scene toward the beginning of the episode, as Riley and Buffy play football. |
| 14 | Mad Cow | Blasé | 3x06 - Band Candy | This song plays as Buffy tells Willow and Oz about her SAT nightmare. |
| 15 | The Cure | Watching Me Fall | 4x16 - Who Are You | This is the song playing in the Bronze when Spike and Faith-in-Buffy have their little exchange. |
| 16 | Bellylove | Back To Freedom | 3x01 - Anne | This song starts during the montage of runaway teenagers, and carries over to reveal Bellylove performing live on stage at the Bronze. |
| 17 | Michelle Branch | Goodbye To You | 6x08 - Tabula Rasa | Michelle plays this song onstage at the Bronze at the end of the episode. As the song continues, we see clips of Tara and Giles leaving. |